The following is a summary of the discovery requests by the defense and the responses from the prosecutor.
Discovery Produced 12/15/2022
I. Defendant — Dustin Pedersen
1. Information & Warrant
2. Booking Sheet
3. Order to Hold wo Bail
4. Jail Extension
5. Affidavit of Probable Cause
6. Southwest Behavioral Health Center Letter
7. Criminal History
8. BMW Murray Sales Contract
9. Divorce Annulment
II. Victim — Nichole Olsen(n/a)
III. Witnesses(n/a)
IV. Police Reports
1. SLCPD report no. 22.229528
2. 22-229528 BMW Inventory Receipt
3. 300 S. W. Temple- Scene Inventory Sheet
4. Kane Co. Report no. 2211103
5. Kane Co. Jail Intake Form
6. Kane Co. Consent Form
7. BMW Info- Kane Co.
8. Kane Co. Property Invoice
V. Search Warrants
1. Warrant no. 2546111 — Dustin Pedersen
2. Warrant no. 2546121 -BMW (Pedersen’s car)
3. Warrant no. 2547271 —KIA (Olsen’s car)
4. Warrant no. 2547231 — iPhone
5. Warrant no. 2547311 — Verizon
VI. Office of the Medical Examiner (OME) Reports (pending)
VII. Lab Reports(pending)
VIll. Photographs
1. Scene (300S.W. Temple; (159 Photos)
2. BMW- Processing (117 Photos)
3. Cellphone Pics of BMW (2 Photos)
4. Charlie Iacono (4 Photos)
5. Christopher Dylan Fullmer
6. Detective Notes
7. Dustin Pedersen
a. Processing (14 Photos)
8. Kane Co. Photos (6 Photos)
9. Kia at Hospital (30 Photos)
10. Kia Soul SW Processing (132 Photos)
11. Matthew Hightower (32 Photos)
12. Maynard Photos of Vehicle (4 Photos)
13. Nichole Olsen
a. Hospital (39 Photos)
14. OME
a. Autopsy Exam (209 Photos)
15. Overview Map of Scene (2 Photos)
16. Tow Company Receipt
IX. Recordings
1. 911 Call Recordings (4 Items)
2. Charlie Iacono (1 Item)
3. Christopher Dylan Fullmer (3 Items)
4. David Maynard (1 Item)
5. Drone Video from Scene (1 Item)
6. Dustin Pedersen (2 Items)
7. Matthew Hightower (1 Item)
8. Phone Calls (9 Items)
9. Surveillance Videos
a. Club Video (1 Item)
b. Exchange Club (3 Items)
c. Surv. Video Parking Garage (1 Item)
d. Video from BMW of Murray (8 Items)
e. Video from Ruth’s Chris (Note: across the street from Temple parking lot) (2 Items)
X. Cell Phone/Electronics Data
1. Phone Extraction- Dustin
2. Verizon Call Detail Records (CDR) Dustin
3. Verizon - Dustin
XI. Transcripts
1. Christopher Dylan Fullmer
2. Dustin Pedersen
3. Matthew Hightower
4. Phone Call w/ Dylan Fullmer
a. Interview on 05-31-2016
5. Julio Cesar Velazquez
a. Interview on 06-03-2016
6. Chaz Williams
a. Interview on 06-01-2016
7. Charles Nunn
a. Interview on 06-01-2016
8. Samuel Sweat
a. Interview on 06-01-2016
9. Dustin Stipanovich
a. Interview on 06-01-2016
10. Brent Black
a. Interview on 06-02-2016 (Car Ride)
b. Phone Call on 06-06-2016
Discovery Produced on 3/13/2023
BMW- SOUL Photo Measurements VIII.17 (26 Photos)
Note: BWM is Pedersen’s vehicle. Kia Soul is Olsen’s vehicle.Maynard Photos of Vehicle VIII.18 (4 Photos)
Note: these are possibly Maynard’s pictures of the Nissan Rogue that Maynard claims Olsen hit with her car.Surveillance Video- Parking Garage IX.10 (3 Items)
Note: Appears to be surveillance from the parking garage at the Exchange nightclub where the altercation occurred.Jail Calls IX.11 (61 Items)
Note: Presumably telephone calls made by Pedersen while incarcerated in Salt Lake City jail.David Maynard Transcripts XI.05.001-029
Verizon CDR- Dustin Pedersen X.04 (3 Items)
Note: Call Detail Records from Pedersen’s Verizon cell phone.
Discovery Requested 2/6/2023
CAD report from SLCP.
Prosecutor response 3/28/2023: provided.
BWC footage for all SLCPD officers responding to any location having to do with this case (SLC 2022-228528).
Prosecutor response 3/28/2023: provided.
BWC footage/audio recording of all interaction between the defendant and any member of the Kane County Sheriff’s Office as it relates to KCSO Incident S2211103 and SLCPD case number 2022-229528.
Prosecutor response 3/28/2023: SLCPD has no knowledge of any video from Kane County Sheriff. All audio recordings at Kane County Sheriff's Office have been previously produced.
BWC footage/audio recording of all interaction between the defendant’s mother Keiran Chatterley and any member of the Kane County Sheriff’s Office, Salt Lake City Police Department, anc Salt Lake County Sheriff’s Office.
Prosecutor response 3/28/2023: SLCPD has no knowledge of this item existing.BWC footage/audio recording of all interactions between the defendant’s stepfather William “Bill” Chatterley and any member of the Kane County Sheriff’s Office, Salt Lake City Police Department, anc Salt Lake County Sheriff’s Office.
Prosecutor response 3/28/2023: SLCPD has no knowledge of this item existing.Video/audio recordings of any interaction between the defendant and any member of the Salt Lake City Police Department.
Prosecutor response 3/28/2023: SLCPD has no knowledge of any video. All audio recordings have been previously produced.Video recordings of police interviews with Charlie Iacono, Christopher “Dylan” Fullmer, Matthew “PJ” Hightower, and David Maynard.
Prosecutor response 3/28/2023: All items previously produced.Photographs of victim’s clothing in SLCPD evidence
Prosecutor response 3/28/2023: All existing items previously produced.Photographs of defendant’s clothing in SLCPD evidence.
Prosecutor response 3/28/2023: All existing items previously produced.Any photographs of David Maynard taken by or provided to police.
Prosecutor response 3/28/2023: Item does not exist.The voicemail left by Christopher Dylan Fullmer’s cell phone on Charlie Iacono’s cell phone during the shooting incident as provided to Det. Wiley by Iacono.
Prosecutor response 3/28/2023: Item previously produced.Results of AFIS search for prints recovered by SLCPD crime lab from the hood of the defendant’s BMW.
Prosecutor response 3/28/2023: Lab results pending.Criminal histories of Charlie Iacono, Christopher “Dylan” Fullmer, Matthew “PJ” Hightower and David Maynard.
Prosecutor response 3/28/2023: Utah criminal history of requested witnesses pending.License plate number and contact information for the owner of the alleged hit and run victim vehicle, a white Nissan Rogue, photographed by David Maynard and provided to SLCPD.
Prosecutor response 3/28/2023: Photo previously produced. Additional items requested do not exist at this time.Browsing history on David Maynard’s cellular device for November 20, 2022 and November 21, 2022.
Prosecutor response 3/28/2023: SLCPD does not possess this evidence.
Discovery Requested 5/15/2023
Salt Lake City Police video recorded interviews of Charlie Iacano, Christopher Dylan Fullmer, Matthew Hightower.
Prosecutor Response 6/14/2023: The Salt Lake City Police video recorded interviews of Charlie Iacano, Christopher Dylan Fullmer, and Matthew Hightower, were provided in the Fourth Supplemental Response to Request for Discovery on June 14, 2023.WebEx video recording of David Maynard interview by detectives.
Prosecutor Response 6/14/2023: A Webex video recording of David Maynard interview by Detectives does not exist.Voicemail sent to Det. Wiley from Charlie Iacono which was left on her phone by Christopher Dylan Fullmer while the altercation at the heart of the current matter was in progress.
Prosecutor Response 6/14/2023: A voicemail sent to Det. Wiley from Charlie Iacono which was left on her phone by Christopher Dylan Fullmer while the altercation at the heart of the current matter was in progress, was provided in the Fourth Supplemental Response to Request for Discovery on June 14, 2023.Photographs of the victim's clothing collected by police at Primary Children's Hospital and booked into police evidence by Officer Rodriguez U80.
Prosecutor Response 6/14/2023: Photographs of the victim's clothing collected by police at Primary Children's Hospital and booked into police evidence by Officer Rodriguez U80, were provided in the Fourth Supplemental Response to Request for Discovery on June 14, 2023.Body Worn Camera footage from Officer Benjamin Richeson V51, who indicated in a CAD note, "AXON USED".
Prosecutor Response 6/14/2023: Body Worn Camera footage from Officer Benjamin Richeson V51, who indicated in a CAD note, "AXON USED", was provided in the Fourth Supplemental Response to Request for Discovery on June 14, 2023.Body Worn Camera footage from Officer Brendyn Scott O89 at 300 S West Temple scene.
Prosecutor Response 6/14/2023: Body Worn Camera footage from Officer Brendyn Scott O89 at 300 S West Temple scene. All body cam footage the State is aware of was provided in the Fourth Supplemental Response to Request for Discovery on June 14, 2023. We are unaware of any additional footage at this time, but the State is aware of its ongoing duty to provide discovery and will provide any additional evidence in the event the State later becomes aware of new evidence.Body Worn Camera footage from Officer Shawn Bennett O90.
Prosecutor Response 6/14/2023: Body Worn Camera footage from Officer Shawn Bennett O90. All body camera footage the State is aware of was provided in the Fourth Supplemental Response to Request for Discovery on June 14, 2023. We are unaware of any additional footage at this time, but the State is aware of its ongoing duty to provide discovery and will provide any additional evidence in the event the State later becomes aware of new evidence.AFIS/AFIT results, if any, of latent finger- and palm-prints recovered from the hood of Defendant's BMW.
Prosecutor Response 6/14/2023: AFIS/AFIT results, if any, of latent finger- and palm-prints recovered from the hood of Defendant's BMW, are being processed at the Utah State Crime Lab. The results will be provided in discovery upon receipt from the Utah State Crime Lab.
Prosecutor Response 8/7/2023: In response to your Request for Discovery, the following item was disclosed via an evidence.com link: SLCPD Report – 22-229528 – Latent Comparison Report IV.11.001-006.Vehicle registration information for white Nissan Rogue parked in Exchange Place parking garage in photos provided to police by witness David Maynard.
Prosecutor Response 6/14/2023: Vehicle registration information for white Nissan Rogue parked in Exchange Place parking garage in photos provided to police by witness David Maynard was provided in the Fourth Supplemental Response to Request for Discovery on June 14, 2023.Any and all OME and lab toxicology reports not already provided in previous discovery.
Prosecutor Response 6/14/2023: Any and all OME and lab toxicology reports not already provided in previous discovery were provided in the Fourth Supplemental Response to Request for Discovery on June 14, 2023.Current address and phone number for Johnny Angel Correa, security guard employed by Reign Security who is captured on Exchange Club surveillance video interacting with all involved parties.
Prosecutor Response 6/14/2023: Current address and phone number for Johnny Angel Correa, security guard employed by Reign Security, who is captured on Exchange Club surveillance video interacting with all involved parties. Mr. Correa was apparently not contacted or interviewed. Therefore, this information does not exist in discovery.
________________________________________________________________________________________________________
Case Status | Case Summary | Court Hearings | Testimony | Dustin James Pedersen | Nichole Family Statement | News Coverage | Other Pedersen Court Cases | Pedersen Letters of Support | Olsen v Pedersen, Maynard